Emily Blunt isn’t merely a typical guest on Jimmy Kimmel Live!; she and the host share a long-standing friendship. Blunt and her spouse, John Krasinski, used to reside directly across from the Kimmels, and the two families have even enjoyed vacations together.

In the clip above, Blunt reminisces about a notable occasion from one of those trips, during which Kimmel grappled with sea sickness while on a fishing excursion — a moment perfectly immortalized in a striking photograph taken by Kimmel’s wife, Molly.

“I do recall you were still heroically attempting to fish in that condition,” Blunt remarks after the photo is displayed. “So you’d go and crumple, and then someone would shout, ‘Fish on!’ and you’d somewhat slither out there, attempt to catch one, and then quite literally slither back and crumple again.”